About the Journal
Mission:
The mission of the IUSTITIA Journal is to present the academic community with the findings of legal and socio-legal research and contribute to the discourse of ideas concerning law and its interaction with other disciplines such as sociology, politics, anthropology, philosophy, economics, and public administration, among others.
Vision:
IUSTITIA aspires to establish itself as a platform for disseminating research, fostering debates, and offering critical analysis from an academic standpoint. It aims to examine issues of legal and socio-legal significance within local, regional, national, and international contexts, exploring the intersections between law and other disciplines.
Objectives and Scope:
The IUSTITIA Journal, an annual publication by the Division of Legal and Political Sciences and the Faculty of Law at Universidad Santo Tomás Bucaramanga, aims to present research outcomes to the national and international academic community. Its primary objective is to contribute to the theoretical and practical discourse on contemporary legal issues, emphasizing a legal and socio-legal approach and incorporating interdisciplinary perspectives from economics, sociology, anthropology, public administration, international relations, and philosophy to enhance the understanding of legal phenomena as multifaceted human, social, and ethical concerns.
The production of the IUSTITIA journal is non-profit and adheres to an open access policy, ensuring that both readers and authors incur no charges. Its existence is driven by the intellectual commitment to scientific legal research and the necessity to make research accessible to an academic audience within the realm of legal and socio-legal science.
Editorial and Scientific Committees:
The journal comprises an Editorial and Scientific Committee consisting of nationally and internationally recognized PhD. researchers with extensive expertise in various legal domains. These committees are further described on the editorial team page of the journal's website.
When submitting articles for consideration by the Editorial and Scientific Committee of the IUSTITIA Journal, authors are kindly requested to adhere to the instructions provided.
General Instructions for Authors:
The IUSTITIA Journal, affiliated with the Division of Legal and Political Sciences and the Faculty of Law at Universidad Santo Tomás Seccional Bucaramanga, is committed to complying with the indexing requirements set forth by the Ministry of Sciences. As such, the following publication rules must be adhered to when submitting contributions:
Unpublished and Original Articles: The Editorial Committee requires that submitted articles be both unpublished and original, without any prior partial or total publication.
Author's Curriculum Vitae: Each article should be accompanied by the author's comprehensive Curriculum Vitae, which must include the author's full name, date of birth, nationality, educational background, affiliations with research centers or institutions, and current position held. Additionally, the Curriculum Vitae should provide details of previously published articles, book chapters, and books, including the title, name of the journal or compilation, ISSN or ISBN, total number of pages in the full text, number of pages in the article or chapter, year of publication, publisher, and country.
Arbitration Process - Peer Review:
To initiate the evaluation process, submitted articles will undergo a preliminary review to ensure compliance with the requirements stated in the call for submissions. Subsequently, the Editor will present the articles to the Editorial and Scientific Committees for an initial selection of materials deemed relevant to the thematic areas covered by the Journal. This review will also assess the authors' adherence to formal requirements, ultimately determining whether the article should proceed to peer review.
Articles failing to meet the formal requirements will be returned to the authors within one month from the submission deadline. Authors will then can make the necessary adjustments and decide whether to submit their work to other journals.
The selected articles will undergo the following process:
Peer Review: Expert evaluators in the respective fields will conduct a double-blind review of the articles. This means that the authors will be unaware of the identity of the evaluators, and vice versa.
Timelines: Peer review shall be completed within a maximum of three (3) months. Upon completion, the Editor will notify the authors of the results and provide supporting arguments.
Evaluation Criteria: The peer review process will assess the academic quality, rigor, and adherence to appropriate academic publication norms of the submitted text to determine its suitability for publication.
Review Results: The author will receive the peer reviewers' evaluation, including the following outcomes:
Article accepted for publication without modifications.
Article accepted for publication with minor modifications.
Article accepted for publication with major modifications, requiring authors to adjust within a maximum of fifteen (15) calendar days. A new evaluation will be necessary following the revisions.
Article not accepted for publication.
Communication of Evaluation: The peer reviewers' evaluation will be communicated to the authors in all cases.
Corrections and Modifications: Should the articles require adjustments in form or content, authors will be given fifteen (15) calendar days to make the necessary corrections.
Non-Response: If no response is received with the adjusted article from the author, it will be assumed that they have abandoned their interest in publishing it in the journal.
Final Opinion: Once the authors have made the required adjustments and modifications, the Editorial Committee will provide its final opinion.
Style Correction and Layout: Articles accepted for publication will undergo the necessary processes of style correction and layout, performed by the Publications Department of Santo Tomás University Bucaramanga.
Open Access Policy:
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution "Non-Commercial" 4.0 International License. licencia de Creative Commons Reconocimiento-NoComercial 4.0 Internacional
The publication provides complete free and immediate access to its content, under the principle of promoting, free of charge, a greater exchange of global knowledge aimed at generating dialogue and academic debate, promoting the visibility of the results of published research in order to promote the use and dissemination of them.
This journal does not require payments for article processing or publication, nor does it establish embargo periods for its authors. The contents are available in full text and without restrictions, therefore users can have availability of the resources in such a way that allows them to read, download, share and take them as a reference for any lawful use without requiring any prior registration or permission from the editor and /or author.
The authors retain the copyright and third parties are granted to copy, distribute and use the works as long as they comply with the terms and conditions established by said license, that is:
1. Share: copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format, giving the corresponding credit, citing the authorship and the original source of its publication.
2. Adapt – remix, transform and develop the material
3. Non-Commercial : You may not use the material for commercial purposes.
The licensor cannot revoke these freedoms as long as the license terms are followed.
Copyright
The authors maintain the copyright and transfer to the journal (through non-exclusive transfer format of economic copyright rights) the right to the first publication, with the work registered with the respective Creative Commons attribution license, the authors authorize third parties to make use of what is published as long as they mention the authorship of the work and the first publication in this journal and when the authors require to use the articles in other contractual activities, they must indicate that their work was published for the first time in this journal. magazine.
Sponsor
Division of Legal and Political Sciences. Santo Tomás University – Bucaramanga Section.
Frequency and Schedule of Publication:
The IUSTITIA Journal is a biannual publication that is published in June and December of each year. Disseminating the calls and the editorial schedule on its website. The IUSTITIA magazine has an open call for articles throughout the year.
Instructions for Authors:
Form of Article Presentation:
The IUSTITIA Journal accepts articles in the following typologies:
Research Articles: These scientific documents present partial or definitive research results, showcasing novel and significant findings in a specialized field of knowledge. They follow the IMRyD structure, consisting of Introduction, Methodology, Results, and Discussion.
Reflection Articles: Original documents that offer research results from the author's analytical, interpretive, and critical perspective on a specific topic. These articles utilize original sources and operate as critical essays, analyzing one's own or others' research findings and providing a viewpoint on their impact on social reality or the academic field. They can also be constructed as meta-analyses of prevailing debates in the specialized field, where the author presents their own thesis based on dominant, alternative, and critical ideas in the field.
Review Articles: These articles organize, analyze, and integrate published or unpublished research on a particular scientific or technological field, highlighting advancements and development trends. They extensively analyze literature, theories, and existing works related to a specialized field of knowledge. Review articles require substantial documentation and theoretical referencing to establish a robust knowledge foundation, current reflections, and analytical abilities. They should include a minimum of 40 bibliographic references.
Structuring Articles:
Research Articles should adhere to the following structure:
I. Title: A concise and comprehensible title of no more than 13 words, avoiding excessive use of prepositions and articles. Abbreviations are not permitted.
II. Author(s): Full name(s) of the author(s), along with their academic profiles and institutional affiliations with IUSTITIA or other institutions. Only the author(s) of the text should be listed, excluding advisors or directors. Co-authored documents involving a maximum of four (4) individuals are accepted for this call.
III. Abstract: A summary of the article's structure and main content, ranging from 150 to 250 words. It should include:
a. The objective or possible hypothesis to be demonstrated.
b. Sections of the document (titles, subtitles).
c. An overview of the results or conclusions, depending on the article's nature (review, reflection, or research).
IV. Keywords: Self-explanatory and guiding terms or phrases that describe the themes presented in the article. Five (5) keywords are required, which should be translated into English.
V. Introduction: This section encompasses the research purpose or objective, a concise overview of the state of the art, historical background, and the practical significance of the results.
VI. Methodology: The chosen methodological approach and research techniques employed throughout the investigation should be described in this section.
VII. Results: Clear and concise presentation of outcomes aligned with the objectives outlined in the research proposal, offering an account of the positive or negative findings resulting from the academic research exercise.
VIII. Conclusion: Interpretation of the results within the framework of theoretical, conceptual, legal, and/or jurisprudential references. This section serves as an opportunity for the author to present general conclusions from the research process and suggest future avenues of inquiry.
IX. References: A list of sources cited within the submitted document.
Reflection and reviewing Articles.
Regarding the two article typologies mentioned, in comparison to the original scientific article, the following structure will be considered:
I. Title: The title should be concise, not exceeding 13 words, and avoid excessive use of prepositions and articles. It should be clear, precise, and easily understandable. Abbreviations must be avoided.
II. Author: The author's full name, academic profile, and institutional affiliation should be provided, regardless of their relationship with the IUSTITIA Journal. Only the author(s) who contributed to the text should be listed, excluding any accompanying advisors or directors. For this call, articles with a maximum of four (4) co-authors will be accepted.
III. Abstract: This section aims to provide readers with an orientation regarding the article's main structure and content. The summary paragraph should consist of a minimum of 150 words and a maximum of 250 words. It should include:
a. The article's objective.
b. Sections of the document (titles, subtitles).
c. An overview of the results or conclusions, depending on the article's typology (review, reflection, or research).
IV. Keywords: Descriptive and self-explanatory terms that indicate the thematic areas covered in the text. They should be clear and precise. Five (5) keywords are required, and they should be translated into English as well.
V. Introduction: This section should encompass the research purpose or objective, along with a summary of the state of the art, historical background, and the significance of the results (briefly and propositionally).
VI. Content: In the case of a reflection article, this section should present the theoretical or practical analysis proposed as a thesis derived from the author's academic exercise. For a review article, this section should contain the results of the analytical exploration of existing theories and works related to a specialized field of knowledge.
VII. Results or Critical Analysis: In a reflection article, this section should include a discussion with antitheses or alternative theories that the proposed thesis must confront. For a review article, this section should present the results of the theoretical assessment conducted to establish the categorization of the impact or importance of each perspective in the specialized field of knowledge and reach a theoretical decision as the author.
VIII. Conclusions: This section should interpret the results within the context of the theoretical, conceptual, legal, and/or jurisprudential framework. This is the moment for the author to provide general conclusions of the reflection or review process and suggest future avenues for inquiry.
IX. References: This section should list all the sources cited within the submitted document.
Final Instructions:
The document should be submitted in digital format using Microsoft Word, with a minimum length of 15 pages and a maximum of 25 pages (excluding the final list of references).
Please use Times New Roman font size 12, with 1.5 line spacing, and standard margins in a Microsoft Word document (2.5 cm on each side of the margin).
The document should include an abstract and 5 keywords in both Spanish and English. Additionally, all citations must follow the APA 7th edition format, both in in-text citations and the reference list. Symbols and abbreviations, such as CSJC (Colombian Supreme Court of Justice), should be defined in a footnote the first time they are mentioned.
Tables and figures must be numbered consecutively, starting with number 1 (e.g., Figure 1). The title should be in lowercase and italicized, positioned at the top of the table or figure, and in Arial 10 font.
Finally, figures and tables should be referenced in Arial 8 font. The document must be submitted by March 30th, Vol. 1 and, September 30th Vol 2, to the email address revista.iustitia@ustabuca.edu.co.
Guide to develop references
References should be included within the text; according to the editorial style manual American Psychological Association [APA], 2017, Seventh Edition, will operate for both citations and references.
Below, we transcribe some examples contained in American Psychological Association [APA], 2017) Seventh edition pages 480 to 497
Journal article with DOI Narrative citation: McCauley and Christiansen (2019) |
|
Journal article without a DOI with nondatabase URL Narrative citation: Ahmann et al. (2018) |
|
Journal, magazine or newspaper article without DOI, from most academic research databases or print version Parenthetical citations: (Anderson, 2018; Goldman, 2018) Narrative citations: Anderson (2018) and Goldman (2018) |
|
Journal article with DOI 21 or more authors Narrative citation: Kalnay et al. (1996) |
|
Journal article with DOI, combination of individual and group authors Narrative citation: De Vries et al. (2013) |
|
Blog post Narrative citation: Klymkowsky (2018) |
|
Journal article, advance oline publication. Narrative citation: Huestegge et al. (2019) |
|
Journal article, in press Narrative citation: Pachur and Scheibehenne (in press) |
|
Journal article, published in another language Narrative citation: Chaves-Morillo et al. (2018) |
|
Journal article, republished in traslation Narrative citation: Piaget (1970/1972) |
|
Journal article, reprinted form another source Narrative citation: Shore (1981/2014) |
|
Special Section or special issue in a journa Parenthetical citations: (Lilienfeld, 2018; McDaniel et al., 2018) Narrative citations: Lilienfeld (2018) and McDaniel et al. (2018) |
|
Newspaper article Parenthetical citations: (Guarino, 2017; Hess, 2019) Narrative citations: Guarino (2017) and Hess (2019) |
|
Editorial Narrative citation: Cuellar (2016) |
|
Authored Book with a DOI Narrative citation: Brown (2018) |
|
Authored Ebook or audiobook without a DOI with nondatabase URL Parenthetical citations: (Cain, 2012; Christian & Griffiths, 2016) Narrative citations: Cain (2012) and Christian and Griffiths (2016) |
|
Authored book with editor credited on the book cover Narrative citation: Meadows (2008) |
|
Edited book with a DOI, whit multiple publishers Narrative citation: Schmid (2017) |
|
Book in another language Parenthetical citations: (Amano & Kondo, 2000; Piaget & Inhelder, 1966) Narrative citations: Amano and Kondo (2000) and Piaget and Inhelder (1966) |
|
Book republished in traslation Narrative citation: Piaget and Inhelder (1966/1969) |
|
Republished book, Ebook or audiobook Parenthetical citations: (Freud, 1900/2010; Rowling, 1997/2015) Narrative citations: Freud (1900/2010) and Rowling (1997/2015) |
|
Dictionary, thesaurus or encyclopedia Zalta, E. N. (Ed.). (2019). The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Summer 2019 ed.). Stanford University. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2019/ Parenthetical citations: (American Psychological Association, n.d.; Merriam-Webster, n.d.; Zalta, 2019) Narrative citations: American Psychological Association (n.d.), Merriam-Webster (n.d.), and Zalta (2019) |
|
Religious work The Torah: The five books of Moses (3rd ed.). (2015). The Jewish Publication Society. (Original work published 1962) Parenthetical citations: (King James Bible, 1769/2017; The Qur’an, 2004; The Torah, 1962/2015) Narrative citations: King James Bible (1769/2017), The Qur’an (2004), and The Torah (1962/2015) |
|
Ancient Greek or Roman work Narrative citation: Aristotle (ca. 350 B.C.E./1994) |
|
Shakespeare Narrative citation: Shakespeare (1623/1995) |
For additional examples, review the American Psychological Association [APA], 2017 Seventh Edition.
Declaration of Ethics and Good Practices
Editorial Responsibilities
The editor of the IUSTITIA journal must act impartially in evaluating submitted texts, while ensuring freedom of expression, and respecting the rights of third parties. The editor must prevent any defamatory or false statements and promote good editorial practices, ensuring full compliance with ethical and scientific standards by the authors. The editor must also protect the integrity of the documents.
Double-blind evaluation will be conducted with absolute privacy maintained by the editor, the Editorial Committee, and the Scientific Committee. Furthermore, articles will undergo a similarity check using the Turnitin program.
If any evidence of malpractice, such as plagiarism, data falsification, or improper citation of sources, is detected, the Editorial Committee will notify the author of the situation to provide the opportunity for rebuttal and defense. After receiving the author's response, the Editorial Committee will decide whether to publish the article in the IUSTITIA journal.
Authors Responsibilities
Authors submitting articles must provide a written declaration stating that:
-
The article is an original work and has not been simultaneously submitted to another publication.
-
They hold exclusive ownership of the author's moral and patrimonial rights.
-
In case of multiple authors, all authors have contributed intellectually to its elaboration.
-
Each author has read and approved the final version of the submitted manuscript.
-
When part of the content of the article has been published or disclosed by another means, the authors must acknowledge and cite the respective sources and academic credits.
-
The current ethical standards were followed in the research.
-
The copyright has been respected, and proper citations have been made for any transcriptions or paraphrasing incorporated into the article.
-
The results and conclusions presented in the article are truthful.
-
They subscribe and authorize in the license of use, the disclosure of the work in the IUSTITIA journal in both printed and digital media for academic purposes and through non-profit dissemination.
- The authors undertake to the journal to provide retractions, modifications or amendments of errors at any stage of the process. If you observe them, The authors must send them by email to the editor, who will proceed in accordance with the statement of ethics and good practices.
Anti-plagiarism Policy
After the pre-selection of received articles for each edition, the article's text will undergo a similarity check on the Turnitin platform. As this practice is part of the journal's editorial policy, authors agree to have their article's text reviewed on the Turnitin tool.
Responsibilities of Referees - Peer Reviewers
If elements of plagiarism or similarity are detected, or if it becomes known that the text has been previously published in another publication, referees - peer reviewers have an obligation to inform the editor.
Referees - peer reviewers must refrain from evaluating articles in which they have any conflicts of academic interest.
Publicity
The IUSTITIA journal strictly prohibits the inclusion of any advertising in its print or digital editions.
Ownership and Management
The journal is solely financed by resources from Santo Tomás University, and therefore, authors are not charged for the submission and publication of articles in the IUSTITIA journal.
Reception and Publication Costs of Articles
The IUSTITIA journal does not impose any fees on authors for the reception and publication of articles.
Digital Preservation
Open Journal Systems is compatible with the system LOCKSS (Lots of Copies Keep Stuff Safe) which guarantees the journal a permanent and secure archive. LOCKSS is an open-source program developed by the Stanford University Library and that allows libraries to preserve selected web journals by regularly searching registered journals to collect new published content and archive it. Each file is continuously validated with records from other libraries, so any damaged or lost content can be restored using those records or the journal itself.
Contents Consultation
The articles can be viewed free of charge on the website: http://revistas.ustabuca.edu.co/index.php/IUSTITIA/issue/archive
And in the following databases:
PLUS ACADEMIC SOURCE EBSCO
The Vlex Specialized Virtual Library.